When it comes to finding delicious sandwiches in Michigan City, Panini Panini offers a menu full of handcrafted favorites that go beyond the ordinary. Our sandwich lineup is made with fresh ingredients, house-prepared spreads, and artisan breads — creating bold, satisfying flavors that keep guests coming back. Whether you're grabbing lunch, picking up a picnic meal, or dining in, our sandwiches are a top choice for locals and visitors searching for quality Michigan City sandwiches.

One of our most popular classics is the BLT — crisp bacon, fresh lettuce, and juicy tomatoes stacked between slices of perfectly toasted bread. It’s simple, satisfying, and timeless — exactly what a great sandwich should be.

For something more indulgent, try the Panini Burger, one of our signature creations. This savory sandwich features a juicy burger patty topped with cheddar cheese, smoky bacon, fresh lettuce, tomato, and our house-made coleslaw — all served on warm, soft pretzel bread. It’s a customer favorite and a must-try when you're in Michigan City.

Vegetarians love our Portabella Sandwich, packed with bold and earthy flavor. It’s layered with roasted Portabella mushroom, fresh lettuce and tomato, fire-roasted red peppers, blue cheese, and pepperjack — all drizzled with garlic sauce and served on our signature focaccia bread. It’s hearty, flavorful, and proof that plant-based sandwiches can still steal the show.